Discover the Melville Coin Show, held every second & fourth Sunday since 1964 at 535 Broadhollow Rd, Melville, NY. Free admission, parking, and appraisals—serving collectors for over 60 years!
Introduction to the Melville Coin Show
History and Legacy of the Melville Coin Show
Event Details and Schedule
Location and Venue Insights
What to Expect at the Show
Highlights for Collectors and Dealers
Tips for First-Time Visitors
Behind the Scenes: Organizers and Volunteers
Community Impact and Testimonials
Future Outlook and Innovations
Conclusion
Frequently Asked Questions
Introduction to the Melville Coin Show
The Melville Coin Show is a bi-monthly event that has welcomed coin enthusiasts, stamp collectors, and memorabilia aficionados every second and fourth Sunday since 1964 Melville Coin Show . With free admission, parking, and expert appraisals, it stands out as Long Island’s most accessible and long-running collectibles show . Whether you’re hunting for rare U.S. silver dollars, world coins, or vintage stamps, the Melville Coin Show offers an unparalleled bourse of over two dozen dealers in a friendly, community-oriented atmosphere.
History and Legacy of the Melville Coin Show
The origins of the Melville Coin Show date back to March 1964, when a small group of local numismatists organized the first gathering at 535 Broadhollow Road . Over six decades, the show has grown from a handful of tables to a bustling marketplace featuring around 25–30 dealers each session . Proudly serving collectors for over 60 years, the show has become an institution on Long Island, recognized for its consistency, community spirit, and passion for numismatics .
Event Details and Schedule
Held every second and fourth Sunday, the Melville Coin Show runs from 8 AM to 1 PM, rain or shine. No registration is necessary—just arrive early for the best selection—and all ages are welcome. The 2025 schedule includes dates such as May 11 and May 25, June 8 and June 22, continuing through December 28 Melville Coin Show.
Location and Venue Insights
The show takes place at 535 Broadhollow Road, Melville, NY 11747, about a half-mile south of the Long Island Expressway Exit 49 Melville Coin Show. Attendees enjoy free, ample parking on the south side of the building, and easy access for loading purchases. The venue’s central Long Island location makes it convenient for visitors from Suffolk, Nassau, and beyond.
What to Expect at the Show
At each session, you’ll find:
- Diverse Dealer Tables: Approximately 25–30 dealers offering U.S., world, ancient coins, banknotes, medals, tokens, stamps, and supplies .
Here’s a deep dive into the “Diverse Dealer Tables” you’ll encounter at every Melville Coin Show:
Each session features approximately thirty dealers offering a vast spectrum of numismatic and collectible specialties—far more than your typical weekend flea market. Local postings confirm that roughly 30–35 individual tables are set up each second and fourth Sunday, ensuring a rich variety of stock every time you visit official website Melville Coin Show .
Dealers at Melville regularly cover every major collecting category: U.S. government issues from large-size cents through Morgan and Peace silver dollars; world coins spanning Europe, Asia, and Latin America; bullion and precious-metal rounds; tokens and medals; banknotes and paper currency; and philatelic material such as first-day covers and specialized stamp issues . Many tables also showcase related collectibles—vintage jewelry, campaign buttons, postcards, and ephemera—so you can pick up a little local history alongside your coins .
Beyond inventory variety, Melville dealers distinguish themselves with on-site services. You’ll find experts ready to appraise inherited estates or mystery lots at no charge; others offer custom grading guidance, rare-piece consignment services, or even live auction previews. Supplies are never an afterthought: albums, protective holders, reference books, and grading supplies are available at dedicated supply tables—everything you need to both find and preserve your next treasure .
Because the show attracts both veteran specialists and generalist dealers, you can expect to compare dozens of price lists side by side, haggle for “bulk-lot” bargains, or hunt down that elusive proof set you’ve been missing. Whether you’re a casual browser or a serious bidder, the diversity of the bourse means there’s always something new to discover—even if you’ve been coming for decades
- Free Appraisals: Bring your items for on-the-spot, no-cost evaluations by experienced numismatists .
Free appraisals are one of the hallmark services at the Melville Coin Show, offered at no cost to all attendees and conducted by experienced numismatists and collectibles specialists. This benefit allows visitors to bring coins, paper currency, medals, tokens, jewelry, and other memorabilia for on-the-spot expert evaluation without any fee or obligation. Whether you’re an estate heir seeking value estimates or a beginner curious about a small lot, the show’s appraisal tables provide an accessible way to learn more about your items’ authenticity, grade, and market worth.
What Are Free Appraisals?
Free appraisals at the Melville Coin Show mean exactly what they say: you can have your items evaluated free of charge by knowledgeable professionals. The service covers a broad range of collectibles, including coins, stamps, tokens, medals, banknotes, and even related items like vintage jewelry and postcards. No pre-registration is needed—just bring your items during show hours, from 8 AM to 1 PM every second and fourth Sunday .
How to Use the Free Appraisals Service
Who Provides Appraisals?
Appraisals are performed by veteran dealers and volunteer numismatists affiliated with the show’s organizing committee, led by promoter George Schultheis. These experts draw on decades of experience to assess condition, rarity, and provenance on-site.
What to Bring
- Coins & Currency: Loose coins, proof sets, banknotes, tokens, and medals.
- Supporting Documentation: Any original receipts, certificates, or prior grading slips to aid in provenance.
- Proper Packing: Use coin folders or small plastic bags to keep items organized and finger-printing to a minimum.
What to Expect
Upon arrival, locate the appraisal table—typically near the entrance on the south side of the building. You’ll receive a verbal appraisal that includes an estimated grade and fair market value, along with tips on whether third-party grading or further authentication might be worthwhile .
Benefits of Free Appraisals
- Educational Insight: Learn how professionals grade and value items, improving your collecting expertise over time.
- Estate & Insurance Needs: Obtain informal valuations that can guide insurance appraisals or estate planning decisions .
- Buy/Sell Confidence: Use appraisal feedback to negotiate fair deals with dealers, whether you’re buying rare issues or consigning pieces.
- No Obligations: Enjoy these services without any obligation to sell or submit to paid grading services—your “second opinion” remains free .
Free appraisals at the Melville Coin Show embody the event’s community-focused spirit and commitment to serving both seasoned collectors and newcomers alike. Whether you bring a single heirloom or an entire box of miscellaneous finds, you’ll leave with greater knowledge and confidence in your collectibles.
- Collectibles and Jewelry: Beyond coins and stamps, many dealers also trade in vintage memorabilia, jewelry, and collectible ephemera .
Alongside coins and paper currency, the Melville Coin Show offers an enticing array of complementary collectibles and vintage jewelry that appeal to a broad spectrum of hobbyists. Whether you’re drawn to the sparkle of antique brooches or the charm of ephemera, you’ll find specialist tables dedicated to these treasures.
Dealers frequently bring estate jewelry ranging from Art Deco rings and Victorian lockets to mid-century gold chains and gemstone earrings. Each piece often comes with a bit of provenance—stories of the families who once owned them or the eras in which they were crafted—adding a personal touch that transforms a simple purchase into a connection with history.
Knowledgeable vendors can discuss metal purity, gemstone grading, and care techniques, so you’ll walk away informed about maintaining your new acquisitions.
Beyond fine jewelry, several tables feature collectibles such as vintage postcards, political campaign buttons, antique advertising tins, and commemorative medals. These items provide color and context to your numismatic finds, whether you’re building a display around a particular decade or exploring the broader tapestry of 19th- and 20th-century material culture.
Collectors often mix and match, pairing a Depression-era token with a coordinating matchbook from the same era, creating unique, thematic collections that tell stories far richer than coins alone.
For those who love the hunt, small ephemera—like old maps, railroad passes, and theater programs—offer an affordable entry point into collecting. Many dealers price these pieces competitively, making it easy to start or expand your collection without a large investment.
Whether you’re seeking a delicate cameo pendant or a set of vintage cigar bands, the collectibles and jewelry section of the Melville Coin Show ensures that every visit holds the promise of a delightful discovery.
- Community Atmosphere: A friendly crowd where newcomers can learn from veteran collectors and network with local clubs.
Here’s a concise overview of the community atmosphere at the Melville Coin Show, drawing on attendee reports, social-media posts, and forum discussions:
The Melville Coin Show is widely praised for its friendly, down-to-earth vibe that welcomes novices and veterans alike. Dealers and volunteers make a point of engaging one-on-one, offering guidance and sharing knowledge freely. Regulars report a sense of camaraderie—many describe the show as a monthly reunion of friends and fellow hobbyists. New collectors often find the environment non-intimidating, with experienced attendees eager to answer questions and help beginners feel at home. Families and multigenerational groups are a common sight, reinforcing the show’s role as both a social and educational gathering on Long Island.
Welcoming Environment
Many first-time visitors note that dealers and fellow collectors go out of their way to say hello and offer advice, making the show feel less like a marketplace and more like a friendly club meeting. One Instagram post called it “a great show” where even “novice collectors” are treated with patience and respect . According to a longtime attendee on Reddit, the show still retains “the old buzz” of friendly banter and enthusiasm that made it popular decades ago .
Knowledge Sharing and Education
Veteran numismatists and volunteer appraisers routinely stop to explain grading criteria, historical contexts, and market trends, turning casual encounters into mini-workshops . The free appraisal tables not only provide value estimates but also serve as teaching stations where visitors learn condition grading and authentication tips YouTube. Many agree that this educational spirit is a key reason they return month after month.
Networking and Socializing
Regular exhibitors often recognize and greet repeat visitors by name, fostering a sense of belonging and continuity . Informal swap meets and “bulk-lot” haggling sessions are common around mid-morning, when the show floor is at its liveliest. Collectors report sharing leads on rare finds, club meetings, and upcoming local events, turning each visit into an opportunity to expand one’s network .
Family-Friendly and Demographic Diversity
It’s not unusual to see grandparents introducing grandchildren to coin collecting, with many tables offering kid-friendly price points on inexpensive tokens and ephemera . The mix of ages—from young hobbyists to retirees—creates a multigenerational atmosphere where stories and collecting philosophies are passed down in person . The free admission and relaxed pace further encourage families to make a morning of it.
Local Community and Economic Impact
Local businesses—cafés, gas stations, and office-supply stores—report increased mid-morning traffic on show days, underlining the event’s role as a community anchor . Civic groups sometimes hold fundraisers or informational booths, weaving the coin show into broader community initiatives. For many on Long Island, the Melville Coin Show is more than just a marketplace—it’s a reliable, bi-monthly social hub that has thrived for over 60 years
Highlights for Collectors and Dealers
- Special Sales and Auctions: Dealers often showcase fresh consignment lots and special bargains on silver, gold, and rare issues .
- Rare Coin Finds: Guests occasionally unearth 19th-century U.S. gold coins or pre-decimal world rarities .
- Stamp Exhibits: Several tables feature philatelic rarities, from classic U.S. issues to modern first-day covers.
- Supply Corner: Dedicated tables for grading supplies, albums, and protective holders ensure you can preserve your finds properly .
Tips for First-Time Visitors
- Arrive Early: Doors open at 8 AM; the best items often move quickly Melville Coin Show.
- Bring Cash and Supplies: While many dealers accept cards, having cash can help snag better deals—also bring a notebook and gloves for handling delicate items.
- Plan Your Route: Consult the show’s flyer or website in advance to identify must-visit dealers and plan your walk Melville Coin Show.
- Join a Local Club: Many attendees belong to the Long Island Numismatic Association or similar clubs—introducing yourself can lead to invitations to private auctions and seminars.
Behind the Scenes: Organizers and Volunteers
The show is produced by a dedicated team led by George Schultheis, a veteran collector and promoter for over 40 years . Volunteers handle setup, registration, and appraisal services, often working before dawn to ensure a smooth experience. Their commitment keeps admission free and parking plentiful, preserving the show’s community-oriented spirit .
Community Impact and Testimonials
Local businesses benefit from the influx of hundreds of visitors each month, and civic groups often set up charitable drives on show days. Regular attendees praise the show for its welcoming atmosphere:
“I’ve been coming since the ’70s—every visit feels like a reunion with old friends.” —Long-time collector
“My grandson discovered his first Morgan dollar here last summer—an unforgettable moment!” —First-time visitor
Future Outlook and Innovations
As the hobby evolves, the Melville Coin Show embraces digital enhancements: online dealer previews, QR-coded catalogs, and live-streamed appraisals . Organizers plan special themed events—such as “World Coins of the 20th Century”—to attract broader audiences and younger collectors. Sustainability initiatives, like reusable dealer badges and digital flyers, will further modernize the show.
Conclusion
For over 60 years, the Melville Coin Show has been a cornerstone of Long Island’s numismatic community, offering everything from casual browsing to high-end collecting. With free admission, expert appraisals, and a friendly environment, it remains the must-attend event for anyone passionate about coins, stamps, and collectibles. Mark your calendar for the next second and fourth Sunday—your next treasure awaits!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the exact dates of the next Melville Coin Show?
Consult the official 2025 schedule at MelvilleCoinShow.com; shows occur every second and fourth Sunday—May 11, May 25, June 8, June 22, etc.
Is there an admission fee or registration required?
No—admission and parking are completely free, and no pre-registration is necessary .
Can I bring items for appraisal?
Yes, free appraisals are offered by seasoned numismatists throughout the event .
Are credit cards accepted by dealers?
While many dealers accept major credit cards, it’s best to bring cash for faster transactions and potential discounts .
How can I become a dealer at the show?
Contact promoter George Schultheis at 516-557-7096 or via the show website to inquire about bourse tables and setup requirements .
Is the venue wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the building offers step-free access and accessible restrooms; volunteer staff can assist as needed.
We look forward to seeing you at 535 Broadhollow Rd—join us and become part of over six decades of numismatic tradition!
2 thoughts on “Exploring the Melville Coin Show”